Posted by: Lisa Hill | June 28, 2009

Hmm, have I read enough American literature?

Chatting with my good friend Sue over at Whispering Gums, and berating myself for not having read enough American literature, I started listing what I had read in a comment reply – and realised it was more appropriately a post…

Some years ago I had an email correspondence with an African-American professor of literature because he’d asked me to recommend some Australian literature.  I was a bit bemused by this, and so asked him what his reading interests were, so that I might recommend something he’d be likely to enjoy.  It transpired that – by his own admission – he hadn’t read much literature other than his own, and by that he meant African-American, not American in general.  This astonished me, because I was but a primary school teacher with a mere undergraduate degree in English, and I had read many of the classic and notable Russians, Irish, Indian, English, American and Australian novels, not to mention poetry and some plays.  (Yes, the French are missing from that list, but I have since read Proust, quite a bit of Balzac and have Les Miserables on my TBR; also I had read Camus.)   I consider this professor impoverished by his lack of attention to world literature, and I can’t imagine how he got his job!

For Whom the Bell TollsAnyway, to please him (for reasons I’ve forgotten) I read Invisible Man by Ralph Ellison, an omission from the American writers we read at university.  We read Henry James (can’t remember which one because I’ve read most of his novels since); Faulkner (Light in August); Carson McCullers (The Heart is a Lonely Hunter); Ken Kesey (One Flew Over the Cuckoo’s Nest) and Joyce Cary (The Horse’s Mouth.)  Since then I have discovered Steinbeck all by myself and have read almost every novel he wrote (I think); and recently rediscovered Hemingway (I think I read The Old Man and the Sea as a schoolgirl) and have a growing pile of treasures on my TBR (and a first edition of For Whom The Bell Tolls!)

In the classics, I’ve read Moby Dick, Kate Chopin’s The Awakening; a couple by Pearl S Buck; some short stories by F Scott Fitzgerland and others by W Somerset Maugham; Breakfast at Tiffany’s and some other short stories by Truman Capote; Slaughterhouse Five by Kurt Vonnegut and The Age of Innocence by Edith Wharton.   In my feminist phase I read Betty Friedan, Erica Jong and Marilyn French but not Gloria Steinam.

I’ve enjoyed ‘popular stuff’ – mostly okay but forgettable except for Jonathan Safran Foer and Dave Eggars; Jane Hamilton, Amy Tan, Alison Lurie, Barbara Kingsolver and even the occasional Jodi Piccoult.  (Some of these are good on long haul flights). I’ve fallen for the over-hyped Charles Frazier and Anita Shreve and found them tedious while Richard Russo’s Bridge of Sighs was excruciating, drivel exceeded only by the tiresome The Story of Edgar Sawtelle by David Wroblewski. On the other hand I thought The Hours by Michael Cunningham was terrific; and I also liked Middlesex by Jeffrey Eugenides.

The guilt starts with the ‘canon’ of more recent writing, the authors whose names are suggested for the Nobel and Man Booker Literature prizes.  Until this week I hadn’t read anything by Toni Morrison.  I’ve read one by Updike (Terrorist), but have two on my TBR, and started but didn’t finish The Body Artist by Don DeLillo – I have his Falling Man on the TBR but can’t make myself begin it. I enjoyed three or four short stories by Saul Bellow, and liked Jane Smiley till I got tired of her.  I’ve read and don’t like Siri Hustvedt, Marilynne Robinson, and especially not Cormac McCarthy.  I have E.L. Doctorow on my TBR, and hope to get to him one day because Lurline aka The Temptress recommended him.

To refresh my memory I checked out the Excel file where I keep a record of what’s in my Reading Journals – there are 165 entries for American authors since I started keeping journals in 1997. 

Maybe that’s enough?

PS 31.7.09

Of course it’s not enough.  I’ve just read Fahrenheit 451 and loved it!


Responses

  1. I think that’s good enough!! As well as I’ve done I think but with differences. I won’t reply to all of yours but mention a couple – and some more that I’ve remembered! I’ve read many Whartons (almost all of hers I think), and a couple of Willa Cathers. I loved Saul Bellow’s Augie March, and I have liked the two Cormac McCarthys I’ve read. I haven’t yet read Doctorow either (in addition to the ones we’ve discussed via comments).

    One author you haven’t mentioned whom I really like is Wallace Stegner – well, at least I loved his Angle of repose, and have Crossing to safety in my TBR.

    However, I won’t go on or I’ll end up doing a post too! Interesting thing to consider though.

  2. My goodness, that’s an excellent round-up. I’ve not read half that stuff and I have spent most of my adult life reading American literature/fiction. A couple of years back I suddenly realised that I was reading too much of it, and took a step back to try and broaden my reading experiences, and so I’ve made slight inroads into reading books in translation and more stuff by Irish, Australian and British writers. But I still want to cast the net even wider…

  3. Well, the problem is that work and life get in the way of serious reading, and so we have to make choices instead of doing it all, eh? While there’s a lot to be said for feminism and all, I do sometimes entertain a wistful notion that had we left the 1950s as they were, with the kids grown up long ago there could have been hours and hours of extra reading time in between housewifely chores. I think I could have put up with it LOL Lisa

  4. Silver lining to every cloud eh? The trouble is that since I retired, I haven’t really upped my reading rate…but I think I’ve said this before. I find it hard to sit and read when I feel (know!) I should be doing other things (such as tidy my piles, catalogue our photos etc). I’m starting to settle into this aspect of retirement, working out times to read, but am not quite there yet.

  5. Know exactly what you mean. A couple of years ago I was Executor of a dear old lady’s estate, and so it fell to me to sort out the house. If ever there were an incentive to set to and tidy up my own place, it was the thought of someone else having to do this for me!

  6. I’ve read quite a few Joyce Carol Oates- and heaven knows there’s millions to choose from! what a prolific writer!- and Ann Tyler and Sue Miller are favourites.
    I see that there’s an exhibition of American painting coming soon, and I’m hard pressed to think of any American painting that I’m familiar with.

  7. Oh dear, me too, I am dreadfully ignorant about art in general. I only know some modern ones: Rothko’s Red; Jackson Pollock’s Blue Poles, Andy Warhol’s Marilyn Monroe and the Campbells soup tins – and that one with the couple standing in front of a barn and he has a pitchfork in his hands. Who is that by?

    Is the exhibition at the NGV, Janine? I didn’t see anything about that in the Gallery magazine?

  8. I like Anne Tyler but have only read one Sue Miller which I enjoyed well enough but wouldn’t seek her out. Joyce Carol Oates is still in my TBR list.

    The couple with the pitchfork is American Gothic, by Grant Wood. And I like Mary Cassatt. I also like the pop artists of the 60s – not just Warhol, but Lichtenstein (love his Drowning girl), Oldenburg (a sculptor who spans a lot of styles).

    I’ve done a little in the way of art studies – history NOT practice – but my knowledge is very rusty.

  9. Of course, yes, American Gothic. I’ve seen it spoofed so many times it gets hard to remember the name of the real thing!

  10. I am a great fan of American writer Richard Ford and his latest Lay of the Land is to my mind excellent. Not that you need more recommendations!

  11. Oh, how could I forget Anne Tyler! One of my all time favorite writers also American

  12. I have Independence Day (by Richard Ford) on the TBR and it is working its way up the F shelf…
    and I forgot to include Revolutionary Road by Richard Yates – brilliant book!
    BTW I ordered Turbulence for my dad for Father’s Day but (having threatened to take ages) my online bookseller whisked it off to him last week! I am looking forward to reading it myself next time I visit (they live on the Gold Coast in Queensland).

  13. I have read Independence Day and rather liked it. It’s the middle one of the trilogy isn’t it? I’d like to read the first one, The sportswriter, before I read Lay of the land. BUT, when will I get to it?

  14. I didn’t realise it was a trilogy… Oh dear… And when am I going to get to Canadian literature, eh? I discovered Timothy Findlay some years ago, and I have about 5 Margaret Atwoods on the TBR and Tragic keeps alerting me to Canadian Giller Prize winners, and oh, it’s just hopeless!


Leave a response

Your response:

Categories